MarriageJanuary 24, 2023|3 min read

Would You Rather Be Right or Be Close?

B
Bret Legg
marriagehumilitycommunication

Some of us have a deep need to be right. We defend our position on things we barely understand, we replay old arguments in our heads to sharpen our case, and we treat every disagreement as a contest we intend to win. And in marriage, that need to be right will quietly cost you the very thing you most want, which is to be close.

Here is a question worth sitting with. When you and your spouse disagree, what are you actually trying to accomplish? If you are honest, is it to solve the problem, or is it to win? Because those two goals often pull in opposite directions. You can absolutely win the argument and still lose the evening, the warmth, and a little more of your spouse's trust.

Being right is not the same as being wise

Sometimes you really are right. The facts are on your side. But being right about a fact does not automatically make you wise about a person. You can be correct and still handle it in a way that leaves your spouse feeling small, dismissed, or steamrolled. And when that happens, the fact that you were right will not comfort you much, because you will be right and alone.

Love does not insist on its own way. That is not a suggestion to become a pushover. It is a reminder that in a marriage, how you are right matters as much as whether you are right. A truth delivered like a weapon does more damage than good, even when it is true.

What we are really defending

Often the need to be right is not really about the topic at all. It is about feeling respected, or competent, or safe. If somewhere along the way you learned that being wrong meant being shamed, then every disagreement can feel like a threat to your worth, and you will fight to protect yourself long after the actual issue stops mattering.

It helps to notice that in yourself. The next time you feel that hot urge to prove your point, pause and ask, "What am I actually protecting right now?" Sometimes the honest answer is not "the truth." It is "my pride." And naming that, quietly, in your own head, can take a lot of air out of the fight.

The freedom of going first

Some of the most powerful words in a marriage are also the hardest to say. "You know what, you might be right." "I did not think about it that way." "I am sorry, I handled that badly." Those words feel like losing. They are actually a kind of strength, because they take real security to say. Only a person who is not afraid of being wrong can offer them freely.

And here is what tends to happen. When you stop white-knuckling your position and genuinely consider your spouse's, they usually soften too. Defensiveness feeds defensiveness, but humility invites humility. The fastest way to end a standoff is often for one person to lay down their weapon first.

So the next time you feel that familiar pull to win, ask yourself the real question. Would you rather be right, or would you rather be close? Most days, you cannot have both in the same breath. Choose closeness. Being right is a lonely trophy to hold at the end of the day, and closeness is the thing you got married for in the first place.

← Back to Blog

Related Posts